The cost of a metal roof vs shingles is one of the most significant factors homeowners consider when selecting a roofing material. Replacing a roof is a major investment, and choosing the right material can have long-term implications for your home’s durability, energy efficiency, and aesthetics.
This guide will help you make an informed decision by covering:
- The pros and cons of metal roofs and asphalt shingles roofs
- A detailed 2025 cost comparison
- Maintenance requirements and return on investment insights
Whether you’re replacing an existing roof or building a new home, here’s everything you need to consider.
The Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs
Metal roofs have gained popularity in recent years due to their impressive longevity, energy efficiency, and modern appeal. Let’s explore the various pros and cons in detail to better understand if this durable and sustainable roofing material suits your specific needs and preferences.
✅ Pros of Metal Roofs
- Longevity: Metal roofs often last 50+ years, with some standing strong for up to 70 years, providing long-term value.
- Durability: They can survive extreme weather like heavy rain, hail, snow, and high winds. Plus, they’re fire-resistant.
- Energy Efficiency: Reflective metal surfaces reduce heat absorption, lowering cooling costs by up to 25%.
- Low Maintenance: Metal roofs require little care, with no concerns about rotting, warping, or pest infestations.
- Environmentally Friendly: They’re often made from recyclable materials and reduce the need for excess heating and cooling.
❌ Cons of Metal Roofs
- Higher Initial Cost: The upfront cost of installation is higher compared to an asphalt shingle roof.
- Noise: Rain and hail can sound louder on metal roofs, although insulation can minimize this issue.
- Limited Style: While available in various colors and finishes, they may not offer the same variety as shingles.
- Potential Denting: Severe hailstorms or fallen branches can dent certain metal roofing systems.
The Pros and Cons of Shingle Roofs
Shingle roofs, particularly asphalt shingle roofs, have been a classic and reliable choice for homeowners for decades. Known for their affordability and versatility, they remain a popular roofing option. Here’s a detailed breakdown of their pros and cons to help you decide if they’re the right fit for your home.
✅ Pros of Shingle Roofs
- Lower Initial Cost: Asphalt shingles are the more affordable option, ideal for homeowners on a tight budget.
- Aesthetic Variety: They come in an extensive range of styles, colors, and textures to suit various tastes.
- Ease of Repairs: Individual shingles are easy to replace, extending the roof’s overall lifespan.
- Quieter: They absorb more sound, offering a peaceful experience during rain or hailstorms.
❌ Cons of Shingle Roofs
- Shorter Lifespan: Expect 15 to 30 years compared to metal’s 40+ years.
- Less Durable: More vulnerable to weather damage and issues like mold, rot, or algae growth.
- Higher Maintenance: Routine inspections and repairs are needed to maintain their structure.
- Lower Energy Efficiency: Shingles absorb heat, leading to higher cooling costs in hot climates.
Cost of Metal Roof vs Shingles in 2025
Understanding the cost of a roof involves looking at both upfront and long-term expenses, which can vary significantly depending on the materials chosen. Here’s how the two common roofing materials compare in terms of upfront costs.
Upfront Costs
Metal Roofing
- Cost per square foot: $6.00 to $13.50
- Average cost for a 1,800-square-foot roof: $10,800 to $24,300
Metal roofing tends to be more expensive upfront due to the higher cost of materials like aluminum, steel, or copper. Additionally, factors such as the complexity of the roof design and installation requirements can drive costs even higher. However, many homeowners see this as a long-term investment due to the durability and longevity of metal roofs.
Asphalt Shingles
- Cost per square foot: $4.00 to $6.50
- Average cost for a 1,800-square-foot roof: $7,200 to $11,700
Asphalt shingles are much more affordable upfront, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners. While the costs are lower, homeowners should also consider the shorter lifespan and potential for more frequent replacements when compared to metal roofing. This affordability makes asphalt shingles an attractive option for those who need a quick and cost-effective solution.
Long-Term Costs
Metal Roofing
- Lifespan of 40 to 70 years means fewer replacements over time.
- Low maintenance, requiring periodic inspections.
- Energy savings of up to 25% on cooling costs can offset the higher upfront investment.
Asphalt Shingles
- Lifespan of 15 to 30 years means more frequent replacements.
- Repairs and maintenance can add up over time, especially in severe weather conditions.
- Lower energy efficiency often results in higher cooling costs in hot months.
Labor Costs
- Metal Roofing: Higher labor costs due to specialized installation techniques and the heavier materials used. However, the long lifespan reduces the frequency of labor-related expenses over time.
- Asphalt Shingles: Lower labor costs due to easier installation and widespread availability of skilled installers. Frequent replacements, however, can increase cumulative labor expenses.
Return on Investment (ROI)
Asphalt Shingles
- Homeowners can expect to recoup 50% to 60% of the upfront cost when selling their property. This is a popular roofing material option due to its affordability and widespread availability, though it may not offer the highest resale value.
Metal Roofing
- Offers a higher ROI at 60% to 70%, thanks to its longer lifespan, superior energy efficiency, and exceptional durability. Metal roofing is an attractive choice for homeowners looking for a long-term investment that adds value and reduces energy costs.
Maintenance Requirements
Proper maintenance preserves the lifespan and appearance of your roof. Here’s a look at the effort involved for each roofing material.
Metal Roofs
- Minimal maintenance is required.
- Inspect for loose screws or fasteners annually.
- Occasional cleaning or a paint touch-up keeps it looking sharp.
Shingle Roofs
- Requires regular inspections to detect damaged or missing shingles.
- May need treatment for moss or algae in damp climates.
- More frequent repairs or replacements are likely over its shorter lifespan.
Maintenance Costs
The cost of maintaining a roof can vary significantly depending on the material and the frequency of upkeep. Metal roofs typically have lower maintenance costs due to their durability and minimal repair needs, averaging only periodic inspections and occasional touch-ups. Shingle roofs, on the other hand, often incur higher maintenance expenses over time, as they require more frequent repairs, moss or algae treatments, and the replacement of worn or damaged shingles.
Proper maintenance planning can help manage these costs and extend the roof’s overall lifespan.
3 Steps to Decide Between Metal and Shingle Roofs
💵 Evaluate Your Budget
If upfront costs are a major concern for your budget, asphalt shingles may be the better short-term choice due to their affordability. However, while they may be cheaper initially, metal roofs can save you significantly more money over time through energy efficiency and longevity.
📍 Consider Your Location
Do you live in an area with extreme weather conditions, such as heavy snow, high winds, or intense heat? If so, the superior durability and excellent energy efficiency of metal roofs are definitely worth considering as a long-term investment for your home.
✨ Think About Aesthetic Preferences
If your home design calls for a classic, versatile look with plenty of color and texture options, asphalt shingles offer more flexibility. On the other hand, if you’re aiming for a sleek, modern aesthetic, metal roofing is a standout choice that truly shines.
Why Choose O’Donnell Roofing?
Deciding between metal roofs and asphalt shingles can feel daunting, but O’Donnell Roofing is here to guide you every step of the way. With decades of expertise in all types of roofing material, we’re committed to helping you find the perfect solution tailored to your needs, budget, and style.
Our trusted team provides:
- Personalized consultations to weigh costs and benefits for your unique project
- Skilled installation for both metal roofing and asphalt shingles
- Reliable support to ensure your roof lasts for decades to come
Contact us today to make an investment that will provide you with greater value and increased life expectancy in the future. Your perfect roof starts here!
FAQs
Is a metal roof worth the extra cost?
Yes, if you’re looking for a long-term investment that offers durability, energy efficiency, and low maintenance.
Can a metal roof lower energy bills?
Yes, metal roofs reflect sunlight, which can significantly lower cooling costs, especially in hot climates.
Are metal roofs more fire-resistant than shingle roofs?
Yes, metal roofs are more fire-resistant than asphalt shingles. Metal is non-combustible, which means it will not catch fire, whereas asphalt shingles are flammable. This makes metal roofs a better option in areas prone to wildfires or high temperatures.
